The group of Idia, Ortho, Leona, the prefect, Grim, Silver and Sebek arrives in Deuce‘s dream, where the dorms are gangs locked in nonstop battles over turf within the school.
They go to defend the library from other students using blank books as weapons. As Deuce has not read any of the books, he cannot imagine their content.
Sebek confronts Deuce for not being a true honor student. Dream-Ace tries to convince Deuce that everything makes sense, but Grim points out that Ace is never that nice to Deuce, successfully awakening him.
They move to Cater’s dream where he is Housewarden of Heartslabyul.
Heartslabyul is having a trial for a student accused of annoying Cater. Cater asks Riddle to take off the student’s head, but Trey interrupts to suggest they hear from witnesses.
They call on the prefect, Grim, Leona and Silver, and realize that it is Cater’s unbirthday, leading to the launching of an Unbirthday Party. Trey prepares spicy food while Riddle DJs.
Deuce wonders if Cater has an issue with Riddle and Leona says he probably does, telling Deuce how Heartslabyul before Riddle was a run-down dump where anarchy reigned.
Leona and Idia suggest that Trey and Cater possible propped up Riddle as an impressionable king whom they would be able to control.
Trey, Riddle, Ace and Cater start encouraging the group to eat and drink at the party, revealing that all of them, including Cater, are darkness.
It is revealed that Cater was never Cater, but a clone made from his own unique magic, and Ortho wonders if they were fooled because Cater views himself objectively even in his dreams.
The real Cater appears and dream-Riddle tries to protect him. Trey tells Cater that he will handle everything on Cater’s behalf, successfully awakening Cater.
Cater saves Grim and Deuce from dream-Riddle’s unique magic and defeats the darkness.
Dream-Riddle calls him Housewarden and Dream-Trey asks him not to leave them, which Cater says they would never say.
Deuce approaches Cater about being unhappy in Heartslabyul but Cater assures him he is not interested in taking the housewarden spot from Riddle and he would probably lose if he tried.
Cater insists that he and Trey would never take advantage of younger students and Leona is unconvinced, but Deuce decides to believe in Cater.
Cater privately wonders why he had such a dream. While assuring Silver that he is already over it, he asks Silver to keep it a secret from Riddle.
They move on to the next dream.
Twisted Wonderland Reference Note 