How the English Versions of Twisted Wonderland Changed Cater Diamond: Game, Anime, Manga & Novel Comparisons

A comparison of Cater in the original story and the English adaptations, including the game app, anime subtitles and dub, manga, and novels, documenting changes to Cater’s dialogue, characterization, relationships, and story details.

Changes to Cater on EN-Server

Twisted Wonderland Website: A third-year student in Heartslabyul. A guy with strong communication skills who is good at reading the room. He knows a lot about being popular, food, and trends. However, he can sometimes be rather cold……
Twisted Wonderland Website (EN): Casual and carefree, this expert room-reader is often called on to mediate between others. He’s always on top of the latest trends, and has an exhaustive familiarity with social media in all its forms.

Original Cater: Welcome to Heartslabyul, the dorm ruled by a strict “Queen” ♪
EN Cater: Play croquet with me!


Original Cater: When my unique magic had only just manifested, I could only make one clone.
EN Cater: Back when I first manifested my signature spell in my fresher days, I could only make one clone.

EN might be stating that Cater’s unique magic manifested in his first year at NRC, but this has not been canonically confirmed: it is possible that Cater became capable of using his unique magic before, during or after his first year at the school.


One of the ways this manifests is how he is often describing the people and things around him as “cute.” 

This character trait comes up on both servers but not as often in the English-language adaptation, where it is rewritten or removed about 25% of the time.


Original Cater: ……

EN Cater: Sec. Cay-Cay’s gotchu.


Original Cater: (^〇^)♪ (ゝω・)☆ d(´v`*)b

EN Cater: 😀 :3 XD ^_^


Original Ruggie (about Cater): Or maybe it was love at first sight? At that age, you were probably her first crush. What a heartbreaker~

EN Ruggie (about Cater): Then again, maybe she really was starstruck by you. Kids are quick to cling to anyone they think is cool at that age.


Cater is portrayed as something as a flirt from early on in Book 1 when Trey has to tell him to calm down.

This trait carries over into a vignette where Cater talks about how Epel must have a beautiful older sister (“If not, he always has a mother”), which was removed from EN.

Original Cater: He’s totally the cutest~! If he has an older sister, don’t you think she must be absolutely beautiful?

EN Cater: Because he’s as cute as a button! And he looks like the kinda guy who wouldn’t leave his dirty dishes all over the place.


Original Cater: That’s not a prediction, that’s something you’re wishing for. But there’s no guarantee that he even has an older sister, right?

EN Cater: Are you sure you don’t just want him to clean up YOUR dirty dishes?


Original Cater: If not he always has a mother…I’m joking, I’m joking!! Trey-kun, were you surprised?

EN Cater: I’ve been better about that lately!

Also removed from the English-language adaptation of the game was Cater’s line about wanting to date Vil, and Vil responding that he is too expensive for Cater to afford.


Original Cater: For a moment there I think I even wanted to date you ♪

EN Cater: Is this even real? Am I dreaming?


Original Vil: Yes, yes. That’s a lot more expensive than the cost of a single photo, so prepare yourself.

EN Vil: Yes, yes. You should feel lucky there is no price for dreaming of me.


Original Cater: Don’t I know it. I bet there is a lot of time and money involved in preparing even a single gift when you’re dating Vil-kun.

EN Cater: Don’t I know it.


Original VIl: If you’re not prepared for that, then stop with being ridiculous and take your seat.

EN Vil: And since you could never hope to afford taking a photograph with me, stop with your jokes and take your seat.


Original Cater: He really left. He’s the type to finish all of his summer vacation homework on the first day.

EN Cater: That nerd really left me in the lurch… I bet when they give homework over holiday breaks, he does it all on the first day, too.


Original Cater: Ah! Let’s all take a commemorative photo!

EN Cater: Оkay, MOM. Now, if you’re done nagging…we should take a pre-game pic!


Original Cater: Ugh, you’re totally forcing me to do it. This demon vice-housewarden, blackhearted-brute~!

EN Cater: Ugh, you aren’t even giving me a choice. You’re no better than Riddle, man!


Original Cater: Wait a sec, Riddle-kun! You only just recovered from the blot, you can’t do that!

EN Cater: Whoa, Riddle, stop! Don’t be a hero, man!


Original Cater: Your whole “not saying what you think” thing is really not good.

EN Cater: I should have learned by now that keeping your feelings on the DL is not a great idea.


Original Cater: C’mon Trey, you sound like a dad on Parents’ Day at school~

EN Cater: C’mon, Trey. You sound like a PTA mom!


If you thought it was odd that Cater commented on competing “against” Vil in Book 5, you are correct: it was originally “competing with,” mistranslated on EN.


Cater’s siblings were changed from two older sisters to zero, since corrected on EN.


What the English-language game has changed to “teeth,” was originally “yaeba,” which means, “snaggle tooth.” It is mentioned in the game guide that “Cater is a yaeba character,” which is why it might sometimes look like he has a fang.

There is a lot of room for misunderstanding in a game where fanged characters tend to label someone as fae or a beast-person, and I have been asked before if there is secret JP-server information where we learn that Cater isn’t human because of card art where he seems to have fanged teeth, but he doesn’t.

That is possibly why this line is here (in the original game): in order to clear up that misunderstanding.


In an EN-server dorm uniform homescreen line, Cater says “I should start wearing our dorm uniform”. This is the opposite of what he is actually saying, which is that the player is the one who should wear the uniform. While it might have been intentional, it is also a pretty easy mistake to make.

This is because, most of the time in Japanese, we don’t use subject pronouns at all. Here is a breakdown of what Cater is literally saying:

There is no “I’ or “you” at all―this is very common in Japanese. Everything is communicated through context.

So how do we know that the English translation changed the subject pronoun if there isn’t one to change? Because of the the verb form! He is specifically saying “着てみる?” (kite-miru) as in “try wearing something never worn before, for the first time?” This verb flexibility is a large part of why pronouns and subjects often get dropped from natural conversation, for being unnecessary.

There is also “かも”(kamo), for maybe/possibly/etc, which is the last word after “look good” in the second sentence of his actual line but was moved to the start of his first sentence on EN, the same words put in a different order, completely changing their meaning.


Changes to Cater in the Twisted Wonderland Anime Sub and Dub

※ Note: Screenshots below were publicly released by official Twisted Wonderland social media accounts and were not taken from Disney+. As a result, some do not reflect the scene in which the line was said and are being used as a visual placeholder.

Original Game/Manga/Anime Cater: Mm~ Your fresh reactions are so cute!

EN Anime Sub Cater: Nice. Your reactions are so fresh.
EN Anime Dub Cater: Did you see that? They’re not familiar with our game.

Cater’s original line was taken directly from a different scene in Book 1.


Original Anime Cater: I’ve got other work to do, so I’m super busy~

EN Anime Sub Cater: I’ve got other things I need to take care of.
EN Anime Dub Cater: I’ve got so much other stuff I have to take care of before this afternoon.

There is originally no reference to Cater needing to be done before the afternoon; the party he is preparing for isn’t until the following day.


Original Anime Cater: Since Ace-chan and Yuu-chan can’t use magic: paint.

EN Anime Sub Cater: Ace and Yu can’t use magic, so you get the paint.
EN Anime Dub Cater: But you two are functionally useless, so you kids get to finger paint.


Original Incantation (game/manga/novel/anime): I am this one, this one is that one.

EN Incantation (anime EN sub): I am him, and he is them.
EN Incantation (anime EN dub): l am he, and they are me.


Cater’s nicknames are largely not being carried over into the English-language anime, with “Yuu-chan” being written as “Yuuken,” “Ace-chan” as “Ace” and “Riddle-kun” as “Riddle,” with only “Deuce-chan” being changed to “Deucey” in the English-language dub and sub, possibly because of Deuce’s follow-up line where he asks Cater not to use “-chan” with his name.

Nicknames are an important part of Cater’s character in the original game, manga, novels and anime: more here ▶︎


Original Anime Cater: Next is Savanaclaw.

EN Anime Sub Cater: Next is Savanaclaw House.
EN Anime Dub Cater: Then you’ve got those monsters in Savanaclaw.


Original Anime Cater: Ahh, shit! I get it.

Sub Cater: Darn it. Okay, fine!
Dub Cater: Fine. Shoot. The things I do for you.


Changes to Cater in the Twisted Wonderland Manga

Original Game/Manga: …to improve the queen’s mood.
EN Manga: …to boost the mood.

Cater referring to Riddle as the Queen, removed from the English-language manga.


Original Manga Cater: Thanks for falling so cleanly into the trap, Leona-kun ♪
EN Manga Cater: Thank you for falling right into our trap, Leona, my friend ♪

“Friend” is possibly an important word amongst the main cast, with Cater canonically never referring to anyone at NRC as his friend. More here ▶︎


Nicknames by Cater that are Exclusive to the English-Language Manga
・Deuce-chan ▶︎ Dee-dee (Deuce)
・Gri-chan ▶︎ G-rim / Grimmy Boy (Grim)
・Yuu-chan ▶︎ Hey-yu (Prefect)
・Lilia-chan ▶︎ Lee-lee (Lilia)


Changes to Cater in the English-language Novels

Original Novel: “Usually, Cater does not ever yobi-sute anyone. When he calls to Trey, he always adds ‘kun’ to his name. This is probably one of his skills as a good-natured person. When Cater uses Trey’s name like this, it is only when he is really serious. Only when it is important.”

EN Novel: “Trey,” Cater said, abnormally serious. He usually sounded so lighthearted when he called Trey’s name; being sociable was one of the secrets to his success. And Cater only said his name so seriously when it was truly important.


Original Novel (Cater): “I’m glad that you all look so energetic.”
EN Novel (Cater): “You look good, real hot.”

Original Novel (Ace): “What are you so glad about…you just used us, then kicked us out.”
EN Novel (Ace): “Real hot? Whatever. You used us and then chased us away.”


When Ace confronts Trey, Trey is incorrectly localized as “Cater.” Cater is not in this scene.

When Trey tells Cater he tried to convince Ace and the others not to challenge Riddle, Trey is incorrectly localized as “Deuce.” Deuce is not in this scene.


JP Novel (Cater): Ahhh~~~damn it!

EN Novel (Cater): Aaaah! Whyyyyy?!

Most curse words have been removed from the English localization of the novel.


As Cater’s use of honorifics is an important character point, they were incorporated into the English-language novel via nicknames.

Ace-chan: Acey
Deuce-chan: Deucey
Grim-chan: Grimmy
Riddle-kun: Riddley
Yuu-chan: Yuuey
(no nickname made for Trey)


The EN novel retained the second of the EN-game’s localizations of Cater’s nickname for Adeuce: “Hunting Season.”


Original Deuce: “‘Clover-senpai stopped him.'”
EN Deuce: “‘Cater stopped him.'”

The EN novel incorrectly reports that it was Cater who intervened with an angry Riddle, when it was actually Trey.